Kirkland Peanut Butter Cups
Reese’s now dominates the peanut butter cup scene, but hardcore fans of the Kirkland offering claimed that the phased-out product was even better. They might have loved it a lot, but it looks like they did not recruit enough fans. It was axed because it was simply not profitable enough to keep it in the store.
Kirkland Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips
Costco phased out the Kirkland Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips even though it was well-loved. What made it so special? A Reddit user took the time to say that the chocolate was baked “into cookies, muffins, and pancakes incredibly well. They weren’t too sweet, had a great flavor, and came in an enormous bag.”